Plain and simple, you need both -but, that wouldn’t make for much of an opinion if I left things that way. In fact I think it does go deeper than a simple answer. In my opinion, it is best to start teaching using the sight words. Especially if you have a struggling reader. Most of the trouble that I see and hear from parents is that their child struggles sounding out words/using phonics. Of course every situation is unique, and I am always happy to answer questions BUT, here is my reasoning.
Seventy to seventy five percent of what a child reads are sight words. These words cannot be sounded out, they must be memorized. For example, take the sight word “good”, or “one”. If a child saw these words they would become very frustrated when trying to sound out these words. These words are not phonetic: they cannot be sounded out. Seventy five percent of what a child reads are sight words. If a child does not memorize and know these sight words fluently, they will fail at reading seventy five percent of the time! A child who fails at reading these words, or fails at phonetically reading words, becomes frustrated with reading and begins to dislike reading. If you failed at doing something 80% of the time, you would not want to do it any more. For this reason, many students just give up when learning to read.
At Sight and Sound Reading we want to emphasize the importance of making sure your beginning reader has confidence. A confident reader loves to read! If you have a struggling reader, we suggest giving our Free learn to read program. In this program the students learn sight words, to help them learn to read. The students learn these words in context so that they can see that reading has meaning. This helps build their comprehension skills, and gets them excited about learning. Each day the students learn new words and before they know it, they are reading an entire page of words that they know! We always like to focus on what the student knows, instead of getting the students frustrated by what they do not know. We weave phonics into the lesson and then intensively introduce phonics around day 15. Before you know it, students are reading both phonetically and sight words easily.
There is no question, you need to learn phonics in order to learn to read, BUT, I truly believe it is so important to first learn sight words (in context) and gain confidence before jumping into phonics. Some students do wonderful learning phonics first. Those same students do wonderful learning sight words too. For children that struggle, try our free learn to read program Start the program at a place where your child knows all the words. You want your child to be confident in what they are reading. This may mean starting the program from the beginning. When learning to read, confidence is key to reading success!
If you would like to start our free reading program, enter your information into the form below. I will send you all the directions and walk you through the steps each day.
Want to know a fun tip to help teach your child how to hold a pencil?